Talk:Marine Headquarters/Uber Committee/@comment-4080028-20140206035157

Something new just came to mind a while back and I just discussed this with Zeon over the chat. The topic we have here is about the Will of D. Now normally, every character we have had on this wiki has gained the D. through heritage. From parent to child and so forth. But now we have Frost D. Amy, who, as explained by Zeon, gained the D. not only from being adopted by Frost D. Crow, but because Crow took an initiative, as Zeon put it, and gave Amy the middle initial of his own accord.

Now, let's look at the manga. Currently, every D. we've seen has had at least one family member, whom they are connected to by blood and not adoption, and thus, they too have D. in their name. The classic example being Monkey D. Garp, who's son is Monkey D. Dragon, who's son is Monkey D. Luffy. Then there's those with the Will of D. whose family members we haven't seen or heard of yet, such as Marshall D. Teach. Both examples allow these people to canonically be D's without breaking the established canon Oda's set up.

Even then, it was shown that Sabo, despite being the adoptive brother of both Ace and Luffy, who are D's themselves, did not receive the middle initial, D. Furthermore, we have our very own wiki to consider; in this case, the best example I could offer up on short notice was the Blade family. Every member, save for two, lack the Will of D. The two notable D's are Cosmos D. Blade, which Ferno has yet to explain to me, and my very own Blade D. Kris, who is a D. through her heritage as a member of the Jolly family (whom have consistently produced D's thus far.) And much like Sabo, even though Cosmos and Kris are D's and are members of the Blade family, none of the other Blades have received the Will of D. either. In fact, Cosmos is the youngest legitimate brother, with Nova being the oldest and Ice being the middle brother.

I believe that's all I need to drive my point home. Now, I feel I'm stuck with a real predicament here, and as a result, believe I need to come to my committee for support and advice. So then Supernovas, where do you draw the line as far as those with the Will od F. are concerned? Is Amy allowed to be a D. simply because Crow wanted her to have the initial? Or is this too much for our wiki, and does it actually break canon?

It should be noted we have seen D's be adopted by a non-D. (the Luffy, Ace and Sabo example,) but we have not seen non-D's receive the initial through non-hereditary means, as Amy has.