User blog comment:1NF3RNO/THE TOP THREE GOOD AND BAD CREWS?!?!?! You decide!/@comment-3387274-20110713142248

It depends. I've noticed that every pirate crew has a massive flaw somewhere, so is weaker than another who is weaker than another who is weaker than......

The best is very hard to say. probably look at those who've taken on admirals and lived:

Skyline, Harlequin, Dreaded, and Senshi's crew all qualify there, pluss others I haven't heard of.