Talk:Evolution Isle/@comment-3507136-20150106122550

For an island of such extravagence. I honestly expected alot more detail/info on the way it works. Yes its a mystery for those in the One Piece world... but here it at least needs a good explanation.

While I think the idea of so many seasons is fresh and new. It also seems like a lot of strain on the terrain. I agree with Wyvern that there can be no atmospheric or oceanic storms IN the calm belt... so it would be best to change that if I've misread and you haven't already.

I like the idea of an ever-adapting species or two. But it'd be great if you could keep it at a non sentient being or something to prevent having an ever evolving ultra human... as that'd be well... silly.

I also think that the island holding an advanced form of almost every living thing on the planet? Is a stupidly ridiculous amount. And I think it's stupidly overboard. But that is my opinion. If it were a few different varieties of beasts fair enough, that could lead to some awesome results as well as page creations. But almost every one? No dude. That's just overboard.

Also, if the weather is as ridiculous as stated, would the remains of a former society really still be there? Or would it have deteriorated or been destroyed by the lava or something?

I like the involvement of rumours into how the inhabitants survive the island. Purely because I myself tend to mention rumours alot. :3 So kudos for that~

If the island isn't floating... a Df could be possible... but it makes me wonder... how one would make an island... eat a devil fruit? It baffles me more than a weapon eating a fruit haha.

I like the concept you have here Reaper, but there is plenty of room for improvement and fixing. Other than that, it's a very great concept. Good work.