User blog comment:Marcus Junior/Marc's Reformist Manifesto/@comment-3337232-20161024194226

On a personal basis, this is an interesting idea to me. Cut out a huge amount of One Piece and fill in the blanks as one big happy family. Potentially shoot down any chances of canon ruining somebody's work by ignoring it flat out. That sounds fun.

However.

On a professional and admiral basis, this is splitting the community. I've been keeping tabs here on these comments to see who does and doesn't like it and it's almost even. That's bad. As I've said multiple times in chat and here again for the record, if this proposal was mostly in favor or mostly out of favor, a decision could be made. But it's not. And if that deadlock shifts into one favor or the other, that would be fine. And I've seen FMF's idea drifting around and no offence to you FMF but I don't like that either. I really don't think we need Another wiki.

But anyway, the Ship of Fools stands out from other fanon wikis (including our own sister wiki) for one reason: Its worship of canon. As far as I'm concerned, that's a fact. And that is a fact we have tried before to alleviate with our previously mentioned sister wiki for the people that don't want that. The people that like it here But want to create whatever they want. If we're going to completely restructure the ship, we need to find a common ground where at least Most of the community is happy. Because right now, a lot of people aren't. And that makes me unhappy.

Therefore, I am against this proposal.